TL;DR
Mellow is smaller in dollars than in the last edition, and the reason is the ETH price. The whole protocol, DeFiLlama parent mellow-protocol, stood at $276.36M at its latest point (2026-11-07 20:01 UTC), against $307.6M on 2 October. That is down about 10%. ETH fell from about $2,745 to about $2,223 over the same period, a drop of 19%. On net, ETH came into the protocol rather than leaving it. Mellow Core is $254.48M, Mellow Restaking $21.78M and Mellow Yield $0.09M.
earnETH, the Lido Earn ETH vault, now holds 90,987 ETH, up from 83,294 ETH on 2 October. In dollars it holds $202.9M, which is 73.4% of the protocol, down from 74.4%. Read on-chain today, earnETH's subvault holds 86,053.19 of strETH's 87,340.35 shares (98.5%), about 99.8% of earnETH's assets. In October that figure was about 99.4%.
None of the control-surface findings changed. The Safe that can upgrade every main Vault і куратор Спільний пул депозитів, яким керує код або куратор. Куратор вирішує, у які ринки підуть ваші кошти, і встановлює ліміти, а за це бере комісію. without delay executed one transaction since 2 October, and it was a signer swap, not an upgrade. A log scan of all eight vault proxies and their ProxyAdmins found no upgrade, admin change or ownership transfer since 1 October. Queues are open, and redemptions were being paid out on 7 November. No new incident turned up.
Checklist
Audits & contracts. Mellow's security page (docs.mellow.finance/security, rebuilt 2026-10-15) lists twelve Nethermind reports on Core Vaults, the permissioned Оракул Джерело цін, за яким протокол оцінює заставу. Хибна чи маніпульована ціна може спричинити несправедливі ліквідації або пропустити погані позики., a custom hook and a MellowAccountV1 module, dated August 2025 to June 2026. It also lists a Sherlock public contest from August 2025 and a MixBytes SyncRedeemQueue Аудит Перевірка коду протоколу незалежною компанією з безпеки. Її мета: виявити критичні проблеми, через які користувачі можуть втратити кошти. from July 2026. The February 2026 MellowAccountV1 report (NM_0829) is newly listed but is not new work. Nothing has been audited since July. The page lists no bug bounty, and neither Immunefi nor Cantina appears on it. No exploit of Mellow's own contracts has been found.
Admin control. I re-read this on-chain at Ethereum block 26,365,657 (2026-11-07, about 21:15 UTC). Safe 0x81698f87c6482bf1ce9bfcfc0f103c4a0adf0af0 (5 of 8) still owns the ProxyAdmin of earnETH, earnUSDe, earnUSD, strETH, DVstETH and rstETH. It has no guard and no enabled modules, and getMinDelay() reverts on it, so nothing delays an upgrade. Its nonce moved from 23 to 24. The single transaction (block 26,226,545, 2026-10-19) was a swapOwner that replaced signer 0x8888...d15d with 0x0c61...dbc3. It did not touch any vault. mbhBTC and mbhcbBTC sit under a different 5-of-8 Safe, 0xb7b2...8786. Its nonce is still 4. Across all eight proxies and their ProxyAdmins, an event scan from block 26,100,000 (1 October) to the present found no Upgraded, AdminChanged or OwnershipTransferred event.
The operational roles are mostly as in October. The curator Safe shared by earnETH and earnUSD now reads 3 of 5 (3 of 6 in October). strETH's curator is still 3 of 8 and earnUSDe's 3 of 7. strETH's admin Safe is still 5 of 8, and it still shares four signers with the upgrade Safe. On mbhBTC, a 1-of-2 Safe still holds both PULL_LIQUIDITY_ROLE and PUSH_LIQUIDITY_ROLE.
Oracle. Prices are pushed by a reporter, with no external feed. securityParams() is unchanged on earnETH, strETH, earnUSDe and mbhBTC: a report can move the price by at most 0.5%, and anything above 0.1% is flagged. On earnETH, earnUSD and earnUSDe, a single submitter contract holds both the submit and the accept role. On strETH, the 5-of-8 admin Safe 0xabe2...eeb5 holds both SUBMIT_REPORTS_ROLE and ACCEPT_REPORT_ROLE directly, alongside a submitter contract, so it can push a flagged price and clear the flag itself. On mbhBTC, the 3-of-5 admin holds both roles directly, again alongside a submitter contract. I did not re-read the internal roles of these submitter contracts this run, including the 1-of-1 Safe that submitted mbhBTC prices in October. With about 99.8% of earnETH's assets in strETH, nearly all of earnETH's value depends on strETH's price.
Liquidity & exit. Exits work by request and batch, and Lido Earn has added an instant-withdrawal buffer since August, according to Crypto Briefing. On 2026-11-07 at about 21:14 UTC, one transaction redeemed earnETH shares through its wstETH redeem queue and paid out about 2.7 wstETH (tx 0xbbf7...0049). Every deposit and redeem queue on earnETH, strETH, earnUSD and earnUSDe reads isPausedQueue = false. The pause controllers on earnETH, strETH, earnUSD, earnUSDe and mbhBTC all still return getMinDelay() = 0, so a pause takes effect at once. Requests cannot be cancelled, and Core Vaults have no force-withdraw. redeemInterval reads 86,400s on earnETH and strETH and 172,800s on earnUSDe. earnUSD now reads 72,000s, against 172,800s in the October edition. mbhBTC still reads 31,536,000s, a 365-day lock, and has no deposit or redeem queue attached at all (getQueueCount() = 0). Mellow's API gives an average exit of 1.5 days for earnETH and strETH, 1.3 days for earnUSD and 365.5 days for mbhBTC and mbhcbBTC.
Yield: real vs emission. The yield is real. It comes from staking, restaking and strategy income, with no Емісія і поінти Емісія: нові токени, якими протокол платить винагороди; вони входять у дохідність. Поінти в дохідність не включаємо. and no live governance token. Mellow's API shows earnETH 7.40% and strETH 9.27% as 14-day time-weighted APY Річна дохідність зі складними відсотками, тобто з реінвестуванням доходу. Більшість таблиць на сайті показує APY, а фандинг і vaults бірж показано як APR., but only 3.19% and 3.95% as a 7-day moving average. That gap suggests a one-off NAV step inside the last two weeks, and I did not trace it. A steadier read comes from share prices: earnETH went from 1.0185 to about 1.0236 ETH per share since 2 October, roughly 5% annualised. earnUSD shows 5.54% and earnUSDe 7.42%. The legacy LST і LRT LST: токен ліквідного стейкінгу, застейканий актив, який можна продати чи внести в лендинг (jitoSOL, stHYPE). LRT ще й у рестейкінгу: дохідність і ризик вищі. show 4.057% APR Річний показник без складних відсотків. Фандинг на сайті показано як APR: погодинний показник × 8 760, бо стільки годин у році (24 × 365)..
Holder concentration. Mellow has no tradeable token, so what matters is how deposits are spread. I measured this the same way as in October: earnETH's dollar TVL Загальна заблокована вартість: сума всіх депозитів у протоколі чи пулі в доларах. Показує розмір, а не безпеку. from Mellow's API divided by the DeFiLlama parent. earnETH is $202.9M of $276.36M, 73.4%, down from 74.4%. The fall is entirely the ETH price. In ETH, earnETH grew 9.2% (83,294 to 90,987), and on-chain its subvault went from 78,889 to 86,053 strETH shares. Its routing into strETH deepened from about 99.4% to about 99.8%. One caveat applies to both months: DeFiLlama does not appear to count earnUSDe, now $53.0M by Mellow's API. With earnUSDe added to the denominator, earnETH would be about 62% today, against about 66% on 2 October. That is down too. I did not check who the depositors inside earnETH are.
Track record. There has been no hack of Mellow's own code in over two years. The exception is April 2026: the KelpDAO rsETH exploit hit a position worth about $21.6M, roughly 9% of earnETH, and deposits and withdrawals were paused for 27 days. Lido's incident review (Lido research forum, 2026-05-21) says full operations resumed on 2026-05-15, that 143.98 ETH of the Lido DAO's first-loss cover was used, and that users were made whole. That account comes from Lido itself, and I found no independent confirmation of the payout. Between 2026-10-02 and 2026-11-07, an X search and a web search found no Mellow, earnETH, strETH, earnUSD or earnUSDe exploit, pause, freeze, delayed redemption or loss. DeFiLlama's hacks list, whose latest entry is 2026-11-06, has no Mellow entry.
Worst case
There are two ways this goes wrong.
The slow one is a repeat of April. A curator ends up holding impaired or illiquid collateral and pauses redemptions. The pause is instant, you cannot cancel your request, and there is no force-withdraw. Last time the affected position was about 9% of one vault, and Lido chose to cover the residual loss. That was a choice, not a contract term. Today about 99.8% of earnETH sits in strETH, so a problem in any of strETH's subvaults reaches almost all of earnETH, and through it almost three quarters of everything Mellow holds.
The fast one needs no bug. Five of eight signers on one Safe can replace the code behind the six main vaults in one transaction, with no delay. That covers essentially the whole $276M protocol. On strETH, five of eight signers on its admin Safe, four of whom also sign the upgrade Safe, can submit a price and accept it after the contract flags it. The 0.5% per-report cap slows a bad price but does not stop one. There is no insurance fund and no exit window before an upgrade lands. If you deposit, size the position as if you could lose it to a signer compromise. A $10,000 position should be money you can afford to lose.
Bottom line
Caution remains the editorial status. The October edition held it as an exception, against an avoid trigger that had tripped. Here is what this month's measurements say about the three triggers named in August.
(A) A Таймлок Обов'язкова затримка між рішенням адміністратора змінити протокол і самою зміною. За цей час користувачі можуть вивести кошти, якщо не згодні.-free upgrade exercised on a live vault: no. The upgrade Safe's only transaction since 2 October was a signer swap. The mbhBTC upgrade Safe executed nothing. No Upgraded, AdminChanged or ProxyAdmin ownership event appears on any of the eight proxies since 1 October, and earnETH and strETH still point at the same implementation as in October.
(B) A second exit freeze: no evidence of one. Every queue checked is open, redemptions were paid on 7 November, and X, the web and DeFiLlama's hacks list show nothing.
(C) earnETH concentration rising rather than falling: mixed. Measured the same way as in October, earnETH's share of the protocol fell from 74.4% to 73.4%. But that fall is the ETH price, the same effect October set aside when the share rose. Underneath it, earnETH holds 9% more ETH and routes about 99.8% of it into strETH, up from about 99.4%.
Put plainly, nothing new tripped this month, and the condition that tripped in October has not unwound. In ETH terms it got slightly deeper. The evidence supports keeping caution only as the same exception, not as a cured one. A curator who weighs the structural measure over the dollar share would have grounds to move to avoid. Three of the seven dimensions are red on fund-loss surfaces with no delay: upgrades, the strETH price and queue pauses. If you deposit, you are choosing a vault and its Safe, not "Mellow". mbhBTC still combines a 1-of-2 curator, a 365-day lock and no attached queues.
Data appendix
- TVL (whole protocol): DeFiLlama parent
mellow-protocol$276.36M at the latest point (2026-11-07 20:01 UTC). Its daily points read $266.28M (dated 2026-11-06 00:00 UTC) and $276.47M (dated 2026-11-07 00:00 UTC). The October edition recorded $307.6M at the latest point on 2026-10-02; DeFiLlama's daily point dated 2026-10-02 00:00 UTC reads $303.87M. Against $307.6M the change is about -10%. Peak $916.17M on 2024-12-07 (about -70%). Split: Mellow Core $254.48M, Mellow Restaking $21.78M, Mellow Yield $0.09M. - Why it fell: ETH was $2,745 on 2026-10-02 12:00 UTC and $2,224 now (DeFiLlama coins API, -19.0%). DeFiLlama's token breakdown for the parent shows 85,037 ETH plus 6,026 wstETH (about 92,400 ETH-equivalent) on 2 October, and 92,425 ETH plus 5,601 wstETH (about 99,400 ETH-equivalent) now, a net gain of about 7,000 ETH. The price fall on the October holdings accounts for about -$48M. The net ETH inflow adds about +$15M at today's price, and USDC in earnUSD adds about +$4M. BTC (uniBTC, tBTC, cbBTC, rBTC, all unchanged in units) loses about $2.4M on price. None of the decline is ETH leaving.
- TVL (Core,
mellow-core): $254.48M; $277.32M on the daily point dated 2026-10-02; peak $496.84M on 2026-04-06. Chains: Ethereum $252.2M, Rootstock $1.07M, Robinhood Chain $1.02M, Mezo $0.18M, Monad $0.01M. - TVL (legacy,
mellow-restaking): $21.78M, against $26.45M on the daily point dated 2026-10-02. Peak $916.07M on 2024-12-07. - Vault table (Mellow API
api.mellow.finance/v1/vaults, 87 entries): earnETH $202.94M (90,987.43 ETH, 88,893.38 shares), earnUSDe $52.96M, earnUSD $31.40M direct ($57.10M aggregate), rsuniBTC $8.26M, mbhBTC $7.54M (100 tBTC), rstETH $3.69M, mbhcbBTC $3.57M, DVstETH $3.40M, strETH $3.03M direct / $205.49M aggregate (92,128.84 ETH, 87,340.35 shares). The API'stvl_usdsums to $331.2M because it double counts across vaults. earnUSDe still returns price 0 and total_supply 0. DeFiLlama's USDC count ($31.44M) matches earnUSD's 31.41M USDC, and no USDe line appears among its larger holdings, so earnUSDe appears not to be in the DeFiLlama total. not verified in this review whether that is deliberate. - earnETH into strETH (on-chain): strETH share manager
0xcd3c0f51798d1daa92fb192e57844ae6cee8a6c7reads 87,340.35 total shares. earnETH subvault0xc5901c2481ca9c26398a9da258b13717894bfebfholds 86,053.19 (98.53%), and subvault0x7f515c80fa4c1fcff34f0329141a9c3b20468fe5holds 0. At 1.0548 ETH per share (API aggregate ETH divided by on-chain shares) that is about 90,771 ETH, about 99.8% of earnETH's 90,987 ETH. October: 78,888.81 of 80,306.93 shares, about 99.4%. - Audits: docs.mellow.finance/security (build 2026-10-15). Core Vaults: MixBytes SyncRedeemQueue (July 2026); Nethermind NM_0956 custom hook (June 2026), NM_0930 (May 2026), NM_0891 permissioned oracle (April 2026), NM_0829 MellowAccountV1 (February 2026), NM_0812 and NM_0798 (January 2026), NM_0758 (December 2025), NM_0735 and NM_0703 (November 2025), NM_0682 (October 2025), deployment verification (September 2025), NM0587 (August 2025); Sherlock contest (August 2025). Earlier architectures: StateMind, ChainSecurity, Nethermind, Decurity, Sherlock, MixBytes. No bug bounty listed.
- Admin/governance (on-chain): EIP-1967 admin slots point to ProxyAdmins
0x8b78...ff37(earnETH),0x95ad...66ca(earnUSDe),0xcf2a...d20b(earnUSD),0x94ab...a2f2(strETH),0x8e6c...bf48(DVstETH) and0x17ac...3772(rstETH). All six are owned by Safe0x81698f87c6482bf1ce9bfcfc0f103c4a0adf0af0: threshold 5, 8 owners, nonce 24, empty guard slot, no modules,getMinDelay()reverts. ProxyAdmins0x17a0...8859(mbhBTC) and0x76b6...5118(mbhcbBTC) are owned by0xb7b2ee53731fc80080ed2906431e08452bc58786(5 of 8, nonce 4, no guard, no modules). Implementations: earnETH, earnUSDe, earnUSD, strETH, mbhBTC and mbhcbBTC use0x0000000615b2771511daa693ac07be5622869e01; DVstETH uses0x0000007563180c9066693110667e2232962d93a1; rstETH uses0x0c5bc4c8406fe03214d18bbf2962ae2fa378c6f7.DEFAULT_ADMIN_ROLE:0x0dd7...076e(5 of 8) on earnETH, earnUSD and earnUSDe;0xabe2...eeb5(5 of 8) on strETH;0xd5aa...496d(3 of 5) on mbhBTC. Curators:0xe5ab...769d(3 of 5) on earnETH and earnUSD,0x5dbf...0a75(3 of 8) on strETH,0x9745...6899(3 of 7) on earnUSDe,0x7df7...c6fa(1 of 2) plus the admin on mbhBTC. Signers shared with the upgrade Safe: 4 of 8 for strETH's admin, 3 of 8 for earnETH's admin, 3 of 8 for the mbhBTC upgrade Safe. The signer removed from the upgrade Safe on 19 October,0x8888...d15d, is still a signer on the mbhBTC upgrade Safe. - Upgrade events since 2026-10-02: upgrade-Safe transactions: one,
0x996d4cc69d7b8f44713d2722d2675002af9e5f69588d9f14faa417a90c982884(block 26,226,545, 2026-10-19),swapOwner(0x44a3...f5a1, 0x8888...d15d, 0x0c61...dbc3). No upgrade. No Safe transactions on0xb7b2...8786(nonce still 4). Aneth_getLogsscan forUpgraded,AdminChangedandOwnershipTransferredon all eight proxies (earnETH, strETH, earnUSD, earnUSDe, DVstETH, rstETH, mbhBTC, mbhcbBTC) and their eight ProxyAdmins, blocks 26,100,000 to 26,365,661 in 10,000-block chunks, returned no events. The same query returns earnETH's deployment events at block 24,370,480 (tx0x3d3b6074...5edf), so the filter works. Blockscout shows oneUpgradedevent in strETH's history, at block 23,394,870 (tx0x762cf202...f236), to0x0000000615b2...9e01, which it still uses. - Oracle (on-chain):
securityParams()= [maxAbs, suspAbs, maxRel, suspRel, timeout, depositInterval, redeemInterval]. earnETH and strETH: [5e15, 1e15, 5e15, 1e15, 72000, 3600, 86400]. earnUSD: [5e27, 1e27, 5e15, 1e15, 72000, 3600, 72000]. earnUSDe: [5e27, 1e27, 5e15, 1e15, 72000, 3600, 172800]. mbhBTC: [5e25, 1e25, 5e15, 1e15, 72000, 3600, 31536000]. Vault-leveloracles.Oracle.SUBMIT_REPORTS_ROLEandACCEPT_REPORT_ROLEholders: earnETH0xfbd8...076eonly; earnUSD0xb105...7156only; earnUSDe0xda55...9d59only; strETH0x0000...907aand admin Safe0xabe2...eeb5(5 of 8); mbhBTC0x4476...a6cband admin Safe0xd5aa...496d(3 of 5). The submitter contracts were not opened this run. not verified in this review. When earnUSD's redeemInterval changed is also not verified in this review. - Queue pause:
SET_QUEUE_STATUS_ROLEholders:0x363b...2189plus the 5-of-8 admin on earnETH,0x8d8b...8596on strETH,0xda6d...8845on earnUSD,0x7589...9abfon earnUSDe,0x972a...0cb2on mbhBTC. All five returngetMinDelay()= 0. Every queue on earnETH (14), strETH (10), earnUSD (8) and earnUSDe (7) reads not paused. mbhBTC has 0 assets and 0 queues. ASetQueueStatusevent scan since 2 October returned nothing, but the same query found nothing for April either, so the result is not conclusive. not verified in this review. - Holder concentration: no tradeable token. earnETH is 73.4% of the DeFiLlama parent (74.4% on 2 October, 71.4% in August), or about 62% if earnUSDe is added. Depositor-level splits inside earnETH and strETH were not pulled. not verified in this review.
- Recent-news scan (2026-10-02 to 2026-11-07): an X search through Grok found no incident, pause, freeze, curator change, loss, new audit or bounty. Several X posts from 5 to 7 November say Lido added Firelight loss cover to EarnETH and EarnUSD. A web search found no primary source from Lido or Firelight for that, so treat it as unconfirmed. not verified in this review. A web search found no October or November coverage of a Mellow incident. DeFiLlama's hacks list (1,341 entries, latest 2026-11-06) has no Mellow entry; its only related item is the KelpDAO exploit of 2026-04-18. The April fallout (a position of about $21.6M, about 9% of earnETH; a 27-day pause ending 2026-05-15; 143.98 ETH of Lido DAO first-loss cover used) is from Lido's incident review of 2026-05-21.
Maintained monthly. Methodology: DeFi Research Instruction v2.