TL;DR
Makina is Vault і куратор Спільний пул депозитів, яким керує код або куратор. Куратор вирішує, у які ринки підуть ваші кошти, і встановлює ліміти, а за це бере комісію. infrastructure. Third-party operators run pooled vehicles called Machines, and an execution layer called Caliber runs their positions against a Merkle root of pre-approved instructions. This report covers the dUSD Machine, operated by Dialectic, and the shared Makina infrastructure under it. The question is the same as in the earlier reports: would it hold a $1M market-neutral sleeve? It would not.
Since 2 October the picture moved in two directions, and both moves are small next to what stayed the same.
Governance got slightly better. On 2026-10-09 the Security Council Safe swapped one signer, added two, and raised its threshold from 2-of-4 to 3-of-6. The DAO Safe that holds the admin and upgrade roles is still 3-of-5, every role delay reads the same as before, and the shared Machine beacon still points at the implementation installed on 2026-08-24. No upgrade has happened since. The DAO Safe is active, though. On 2026-11-06 it queued, through the AccessManager, a change to the Chainlink CRE workflow IDs on ten Machines including dUSD. Those IDs control which Chainlink workflow may push cross-chain accounting snapshots. It looks like maintenance, and it sits behind the delay like everything else.
The vault got smaller and more concentrated. dUSD AUM read on-chain is $1,661,575, down from $1.92M. Share supply fell 14%, from 1,834,505 to 1,572,969. The largest wallet did not move. It still holds exactly 750,000 shares, so its share rose from 40.9% to 47.7%. A $1M ticket would now be about 60% of the vault.
Restitution can now be checked on-chain, and it is slow. The recovery contract Makina announced on 2026-07-31 has received one USDC deposit, 40,565.51 USDC on that day. That is about 1.9% of the 2.148M USDC still owed after the January exploit. Makina said deposits would come about once per quarter, which puts the next one around the end of October. None had arrived by 2026-11-07.
No new incident. DeFiLlama's hacks list, which has entries up to 2026-11-05, still shows only the January event for Makina.
Checklist
Audits & contracts. Makina's security page, re-read today, lists ChainSecurity on core and periphery for V1 (Sept 2025), V1.1 (Jan 2026), V1.2 (May 2026) and V1.3 (Aug 2026). It also lists OtterSec (Nov 2025), SigmaPrime (Aug 2025), two Enigma Dark engagements (Jul and Sept 2025) and a Cantina CTF (Oct 2025), plus a Cantina bug bounty and SEAL Safe Harbor. Makina's own V1.3 post also confirms the ChainSecurity Аудит Перевірка коду протоколу незалежною компанією з безпеки. Її мета: виявити критичні проблеми, через які користувачі можуть втратити кошти. of core and periphery. The beacon implementation 0x6a759cae19aa25b41237089eb0bbbc4473bfb996 is unchanged since 2026-08-24. The caveat from earlier reports stands. The January loss came from a Weiroll accounting script inside an approved operator instruction root, and those roots are written per strategy, outside the audited contract set.
Admin control. Re-read from mainnet today at block 26363152. The dUSD Machine's EIP-1967 beacon slot still points at 0x5c680ec39bafe8524f3c2fa9d5f6d65f09bd7333. The beacon's owner is still AccessManager 0x0fCEfa3f1047F35521A49cD8B06faBd588665d7F, and its implementation is the same 0x6a759cae... as on 2 October. DAO Safe 0x62244C74e1d09b3D86EF7342d354b5D7770bDE10 still has threshold 3 with five owners. In the AccessManager it holds ADMIN (0) and INFRA_UPGRADE (6) at 172,800 seconds, MANAGEMENT_CONFIG (4) and FEE_CONFIG (5) at 172,800 seconds, INFRA_CONFIG (1) and LINKING (3) at 86,400 seconds, and STRATEGY_DEPLOYMENT (2) at zero. GUARDIAN (7) belongs to the Security Council Safe 0x89faa3b02EF5aB185b8ACE489Af62748ACB50Afc. That Safe changed. On 2026-10-09 at 14:25 UTC a MultiSend replaced one owner and added two more. At 17:00 UTC the same day a second transaction raised the threshold to 3. It is now 3-of-6, up from 2-of-4. An attacker now needs more keys to control the guardian, and the honest signers need more people to act in an emergency. It does nothing about the main point. Makina's own docs say whoever holds the upgrade role can change all system logic and, in the worst case, take all deposited funds. Таймлок Обов'язкова затримка між рішенням адміністратора змінити протокол і самою зміною. За цей час користувачі можуть вивести кошти, якщо не згодні. and visible, but fully upgradeable.
One queued action. On 2026-11-06 at 18:02 UTC the DAO Safe called schedule on the AccessManager for addCreWorkflowId and removeCreWorkflowId on ten Machines, the dUSD Machine among them. The removal of the current workflow ID on dUSD shows a schedule maturing at 2026-11-08 18:02 UTC, 48 hours later. At today's read the new ID is not yet authorised and the old one still is. These IDs decide which Chainlink CRE workflow may deliver accounting snapshots, so the change touches the NAV pipeline, not the code. Whether the add leg is scheduled the same way, and any other pending AccessManager operation, is not verified in this review.
Oracle. Chainlink is the registry-level price source, which DeFiLlama lists as Primary. That is not what broke in January. Share price comes from an AUM computation over positions, and on 2026-01-20 a flash loan moved Curve spot reads inside a dUSD instruction. DeFiLlama's hack entry classifies it as Оракул Джерело цін, за яким протокол оцінює заставу. Хибна чи маніпульована ціна може спричинити несправедливі ліквідації або пропустити погані позики. Manipulation, technique Spot Price Manipulation. V1.1 added a restricted accounting mode and a cap on share-price moves; restrictedAccountingMode() reads true on dUSD today. Makina's V1.3 post adds Chainlink CRE for cross-chain accounting and describes "a leaner snapshot-based accounting model and additional sanity checks", without saying what the checks test. NAV still comes from operator-written accounting logic. Whether the Security Council can still refresh AUM outside the cap is not verified in this review. The dUSD Machine last ran global accounting at 12:26 UTC today, so updates are frequent.
Liquidity & exit. Whitelisting is still off on both the Depositor 0x94b1828f91c150c5e6776198e170aca4304903d7 and the AsyncRedeemer 0x1303c26cfe06bac5bfee29907f37919643def75c. Redemption is still an asynchronous FIFO queue that the Operator settles. finalizationDelay() still reads 172,800 seconds, so 48 hours is the floor, with no committed ceiling. minRedeemAmount() is 0. nextRequestId() is 446 and lastFinalizedRequestId() is 437, so eight requests are pending. Twenty-four have been created since 2 October, when the counter read 422. The redeemer holds 11,589 shares in escrow, 0.74% of supply. The docs say settlement first draws on a usually small idle USDC buffer. If that runs short, positions get unwound and bridged back. A $1M exit from a $1.66M vault means unwinding about 60% of the book through that process.
Yield: real vs emission. DeFiLlama shows dUSD at 5.85% today, all Базова дохідність і винагороди Базову дохідність протокол сплачує зі свого доходу: відсотків і комісій. Винагороди він виплачує токенами з емісії або кампанії., with no reward component and a Середня дохідність за 30 днів Середній показник дохідності за 30 днів. Його рахує DeFiLlama, де вона його публікує, інакше ми: з денних вимірів, а для фандингу з історії кожної біржі. of 8.57%. The on-chain share price agrees: it went from about 1.0476 on 2 October to 1.0563 today, roughly 8% annualised. The yield is real, but Makina describes the strategy as discretionary multi-strategy, covering lending, AMM Ліквідність Скільки можна продати чи вивести просто зараз, не зсуваючи ціну й не чекаючи. Мала ліквідність означає повільний або дорогий вихід., Pendle and Spectra PT (principal token) Токен Pendle, який на дату погашення обмінюють на одиницю базового активу. Його купують зі знижкою, тож PT до погашення фіксує дохідність., Кредитне плече Позика, щоб тримати позицію, більшу за ваш капітал. Із плечем 3x на кожен ваш $1 припадає $3 позиції, і прибуток, збиток та ризик ліквідації ростуть разом. loops and cross-chain positions. It is not market-neutral. One new thing at the protocol level: Dialectic launched seven tokenized-stock Machines on Base on 2026-10-05, and DeFiLlama now lists eight tokenized-stock pools on Base (the seven plus a SPCXC pool), each showing a 10% reward APY. Makina's launch post mentions no incentive, so the source of that reward is not verified in this review. It does not touch dUSD. MAK token status is not verified in this review. The ICO closed in December 2025, and no launch could be confirmed. Fee parameters were not re-read this run.
Holder concentration. Ethplorer shows 412 DUSD holders. On-chain balanceOf reads match it. The top holder, 0xf46e183e8b010cfdebe57a50064149e65504c2bf, holds exactly 750,000 shares, 47.68% of supply. Next come 0x8fba28fadb19b8c92a3f984ea18a0cdebe3da691 at 14.61% and 0x24a1e70320ad786cafe61c6040d5a09291213ba9 at 5.89%, so the top three hold about 68%. All three return empty code, so they are EOAs. The wallet that was second on 2 October, 0x49655e36... at 13.6%, is no longer in the top eight. The 261,536-share drop in supply is about the size of its old position, but that link is an inference. As the vault shrinks around it, one wallet now holds almost half of DUSD.
Track record. DeFiLlama's history starts 2025-09-30. The protocol was exploited in month four, on this Machine: 1,299 ETH, about $4.13M, on 2026-01-20. DeFiLlama records $4.2M with $3.41M returned; that figure does not reconcile with Makina's own accounting, and this report uses Makina's. Makina's Recovery and Restitution post of 2026-01-26 left 2.148M USDC owed. It is to be covered by Makina and Dialectic each paying 50% of their revenue from DUSD, DETH and DBIT into a recovery fund. On 2026-07-31 Makina issued ERC-721 recovery notes from contract 0x599a1E2f0a4c385c784711432f7D6Ac116184B8E and said both parties expect to deposit about once per quarter. Etherscan's token-transfer history for that contract shows one USDC inflow, 40,565.51 USDC on 2026-07-31 from a Safe, followed by ten note-holder claims totalling 16,054.80 USDC. The latest claim was on 2026-11-02. The contract now holds 24,510.71 USDC, which is exactly the one deposit minus those claims, so no other USDC reached it. That deposit is about 1.9% of the amount owed. If more was paid by some other route, the claim page would show it, and that check is not verified in this review. TVL peaked at $107.1M on 2025-11-29 and is $38.7M today. No second incident found from 2026-10-02 through 2026-11-07.
Worst case
The same three failure modes as before, and two of them are now sharper.
The one that already happened: an approved instruction root reads a manipulable value, AUM jumps, and whoever is on the other side of DUSD gets drained. Timelocks do not help, because the bad input is an approved instruction misbehaving, not an upgrade. The caps and V1.3 sanity checks shrink the move per update. They do not close the class.
The upgrade path: the 3-of-5 DAO Safe schedules a beacon upgrade, and 48 hours later every Machine runs new code. The Security Council can cancel it during the window and now needs three of six signers to do so. It cannot cancel admin operations.
And the exit. Redemption is a 48 hour minimum queue on a $1.66M vault where one wallet holds 47.7%. If that wallet redeems first, the Operator unwinds half the book before your request is reached. If something breaks first, the January precedent shows how slowly losses get paid back: about 2% of the shortfall in nine and a half months.
Bottom line
Avoid, for a $1M market-neutral allocation. The Security Council change is real, if small, and the beacon has been quiet since August. Neither moves the gate. Four dimensions are still red, and two of them got worse. The vault is now too small to take the ticket without becoming most of it. One wallet holds almost half. The exit is an Operator-settled queue with a 48 hour floor and no ceiling. And the share-price surface that was exploited in January still sits on this exact Machine, with restitution about 2% paid. The sibling Machines (USDSHFMK at $21.0M, DCM at $7.9M, DETH at $5.5M) share the same beacon, AccessManager and accounting design, so moving to another Machine does not change the verdict. Revisit if NAV stops depending on operator-written accounting reads, if redemptions get a contractual settlement ceiling, and if restitution deposits resume on the stated schedule.
Data appendix
- TVL: $38,747,150 protocol-wide (DeFiLlama /protocol/makina, data point 2026-11-07 11:21 UTC), with Ethereum $37,188,298 and Base $1,558,851. The DeFiLlama series now reads $45.81M for 2026-10-02, but the October report recorded $38.6M from the same endpoint that day. The series looks revised after the fact, possibly when new Machines were added, so a month-on-month change is not quoted. ATH $107,134,900 on 2025-11-29. Category Onchain Capital Allocator,
parentProtocolnull. Pools (DeFiLlama yields): USDSHFMK $20.99M, DCM $7.88M, DETH $5.48M, DUSD $1.66M, DMG $1.33M, eight Base tokenized-stock pools about $1.56M combined, DBIT $0.59M, others smaller. INTMKSRROYUSDC fell from $7.07M on 2 October to $0.13M. - dUSD: This scope is the dUSD Machine only, not the protocol.
lastTotalAum()1,661,574.83 USDC, last global accounting 2026-11-07 12:26 UTC. Share supply 1,572,968.64 (share token 0x1e33e98af620f1d563fcd3cfd3c75ace841204ef), implied share price about 1.0563.recoveryMode()false,restrictedAccountingMode()true. On 2026-10-02 the same reads gave AUM 1,921,826 and supply 1,834,505. DeFiLlama pool a0387f4b-18ba-5fb5-8171-0f177254dfeb: $1.66M, 5.85% APY Річна дохідність зі складними відсотками, тобто з реінвестуванням доходу. Більшість таблиць на сайті показує APY, а фандинг і vaults бірж показано як APR. all base, 30d mean 8.57%. - Deposits and redemptions: Depositor and Redeemer
isWhitelistEnabled()both false. RedeemerfinalizationDelay()172,800s,minRedeemAmount()0,nextRequestId()446,lastFinalizedRequestId()437. Redeemer share balance 11,589.05. - Audits: ChainSecurity core and periphery Sept 2025, Jan 2026, May 2026, Aug 2026. OtterSec Nov 2025. SigmaPrime Aug 2025. Enigma Dark Jul and Sept 2025. Cantina CTF Oct 2025. Cantina bug bounty, SEAL Safe Harbor (docs.makina.finance/concepts/security/audits, re-read 2026-11-07). V1.3 ChainSecurity audit also confirmed in Makina's 2026-08-26 post.
- Admin and governance: Beacon 0x5c680ec3..., owner AccessManager 0x0fCEfa3f..., implementation 0x6a759cae19aa25b41237089eb0bbbc4473bfb996, unchanged since 2026-08-24.
hasRoledelays: DAO Safe roles 0, 4, 5, 6 at 172,800s; roles 1, 3 at 86,400s; role 2 at 0s. Security Council role 7 at 0s. DAO SafegetThreshold3, five owners. Security CouncilgetThreshold3, six owners. Changed on 2026-10-09: tx 0xec1fcc5b... (block 26155437) swapped owner 0x7140ca96... for 0x72faa01f... and added 0xba084ce3... and 0x08a4c6f7...; tx 0xee41181f... (block 26156207) changed threshold to 3. Queued: DAO Safe tx 0xcacf0293... (block 26357471, 2026-11-06 18:02 UTC) scheduledaddCreWorkflowId/removeCreWorkflowIdon ten Machines including dUSD; the dUSD removal op matures 2026-11-08 18:02 UTC; new workflow ID not yet authorised at read time. Status of the add leg, other pending AccessManager operations, TimelockControllers and the AccessManager's ProxyAdmin: not verified in this review. - Oracle: Chainlink, Primary (DeFiLlama oraclesBreakdown). Share price comes from AUM accounting. V1.3 introduced Chainlink CRE snapshot-based cross-chain accounting with "additional sanity checks" (Makina Substack, 2026-08-26). Whether the Security Council's AUM-refresh bypass survives: not verified in this review.
- Holder concentration: 412 holders (Ethplorer). 0xf46e183e... 47.68%, 0x8fba28fa... 14.61%, 0x24a1e703... 5.89%, 0x56538026... 4.40%, 0xf0f859d0... 3.18%. Top three are EOAs per
eth_getCode, and their balances were confirmed by on-chainbalanceOf. - Restitution: Recovery-note contract 0x599a1E2f0a4c385c784711432f7D6Ac116184B8E (Makina Substack, 2026-07-31). The only USDC inflow in its Etherscan token-transfer history is 40,565.51 USDC on 2026-07-31 (from Safe 0xc22f7346...). Ten claims since then total 16,054.80 USDC, the latest on 2026-11-02. Current USDC balance 24,510.71, which equals the deposit minus the claims. Amount owed per Makina, 2026-01-26: 2.148M USDC. Stated cadence: deposits about once per quarter. Figures on the claim page at recovery.makina.finance: not verified in this review.
- Incident record: DeFiLlama hacks: Makina, $4.2M, dated 2026-01-20, Oracle Manipulation / Spot Price Manipulation, returnedFunds $3.41M. No other Makina entry in a list that runs to 2026-11-05.
- Recent news scan: Makina Substack posts since 2 October: one, "Dialectic Launches Seven Machines on Makina for Tokenized Stocks on Base" (2026-10-05). The post before it, "Meet MakinaX" (2026-09-07), introduces a Safe module and does not touch dUSD. A web search found no incident coverage after February 2026. MAK token launch status: not verified in this review. Source of the 10% reward APY on the Base stock pools: not verified in this review.
- Not re-verified this run: fee manager parameters, Nexus Mutual cover for dUSD, and current dUSD strategy allocation.
Maintained monthly. Methodology: DeFi Research Instruction v2.